【重磅快評】新一波太空競爭 讓目前紛爭變得可笑

【重磅快評】新一波太空競爭 讓目前紛爭變得可笑
2017-10-06 11:40聯合報 主筆室

中秋當晚,有巨大隕石墜落于雲南的香格里拉縣境內,這已經超過隕石等級,而是小行星撞擊地球事件,爆炸當量相當於540噸TNT,相當於一次2.1級地震。

這並不是最嚴重的,在地球幾億萬年歷史中,有無數小行星「造訪」過地球,造成類似墨西哥灣這樣的深凹地形,也曾使得大規模物種滅絕,自有記載以來,以1908年西伯利亞的通古斯大爆炸,威力最大,當時估計爆炸威力相當於2千萬噸TNT炸藥,超過2150平方公里內的8千萬棵樹,焚毀倒覆。

人類對地球以外的理解,非常有限,六十年前的十月四日,蘇聯成功發射了第一顆人造衛星「史潑尼克一號」,才開始探索,但是這不是純然出於科學的好奇,而是混雜著國家競爭的驕傲與軍備競爭。

蘇聯的創舉震驚全球,也對美國造成極大壓力,當時為了加速競爭,成立了美國太空總署與上級指導單位「美國太空委員會」,但是在蘇聯解體,太空計畫也隨之中止,美國在耗資巨大的太空梭計畫結束之後,同樣大幅削減經費,「太空委員會」也告解散。

然而最近這幾年,太空熱突然又開始,主要因為中國大陸積極趕上,從衛星發射,到太空站設立,未來還有登月計畫,印度雖然規模不大,但在無人登陸火星方面,效率成本,卻領先各國,在在都給美國來壓力。

十月五日,美國宣佈重新設立國家太空委員會,副總統潘斯主持第一場會議時宣示,美國將重返月球,並在月球軌道上建成「深空門戶」太空港,作為通往深空的門戶,設定2033年要抵達火星軌道。

新一波開始的太空競爭,將把我們帶到何處,現在還不清楚,但是從太空回看地球,讓我們更會珍惜這個共同生存的「小地方」,也讓目前的紛爭,變得可笑不值得。

Orbital ATK的Antares火箭去年載送「天鵝座」(Cygnus)貨運...
Orbital ATK的Antares火箭去年載送「天鵝座」(Cygnus)貨運飛船向國際太空站運送補給物資。路透

Einstein’s waves win Nobel Prize in physics

Einstein’s waves win Nobel Prize in physics
By Paul Rincon and Jonathan Amos
BBC Science News , 3 October 2017 , From the section Science & Environment

Nobel laureates in physics 2017Image copyright PA
Image captionWeiss (L) takes half the prize; Thorne (C) and Barish (R) share the other half

The 2017 Nobel prize in physics has been awarded to three US scientists for the detection of gravitational waves.

Rainer Weiss, Kip Thorne and Barry Barish will share the nine million kronor (£831,000) prize.

The ripples were predicted by Albert Einstein and are a fundamental consequence of his General Theory of Relativity.

The winners are members of the Ligo-Virgo observatories, which were responsible for the breakthrough.

The winners join a prestigious list of 204 other Physics laureates recognised since 1901.

Prof Weiss gets half of the prize money, while Barish and Thorne will share the other half.

Gravitational waves describe the stretching and squeezing of space-time that occurs when massive objects accelerate.

The warping of space resulting from the merger of two black holes was initially picked up by the US Ligo laboratory in 2015 – the culmination of a decades-long quest.

Three more examples have been detected since then.


Gravitational waves – Ripples in the fabric of space-time

Black hole artworkImage copyrightIGO/CALTECH/MIT/SONOMA STATE
Image captionArtwork: Two coalescing black holes spinning in a non-aligned fashion
  • Gravitational waves are a prediction of the Theory of General Relativity
  • It took decades to develop the technology to directly detect them
  • They are ripples in the fabric of space-time generated by violent events
  • Accelerating masses will produce waves that propagate at the speed of light
  • Detectable sources ought to include merging black holes and neutron stars
  • Ligo/Virgo fire lasers into long, L-shaped tunnels; the waves disturb the light
  • Detecting the waves opens up the Universe to completely new investigations

Speaking at a press conference, Olga Botner, from the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, said: “The first ever observation of a gravitational wave was a milestone – a window on the Universe.”

The US Ligo and European Virgo laboratories were built to detect the very subtle signal produced by these waves.

Even though they are produced by colossal phenomena, such as black holes merging, Einstein himself thought the effect might simply be too small to register by technology.

But the three new laureates led the development of a laser-based system that could reach the sensitivity required to bag a detection.

The result was Ligo, a pair of widely separated facilities in North America: one observatory is based in Washington State, while the other is in Livingston, Louisiana.

The European side of the gravitational wave collaboration is based in Pisa, Italy. On 14 August this year, just after coming online, it sensed the most recent of the four gravitational wave events.

Speaking over the phone at the Nobel announcement in Stockholm, Rainer Weiss said the discovery was the work of about 1,000 people.

He explained: “It’s a dedicated effort that’s been going on for – I hate to tell you – it’s as long as 40 years, of people thinking about this, trying to make a detection and sometimes failing in the early days, then slowly but surely getting the technology together to do it. It’s very, very exciting that it worked out in the end.”

Nonetheless, the Nobel trio’s contribution is also regarded as fundamental.

Weiss set out the strategy that would be needed to make a detection.

Thorne did much of the theoretical work that underpinned the quest.

And Barish, who took over as the second director of Ligo in 1994, is credited with driving through organisational reforms and technology choices that would ultimately prove pivotal in the mission’s success.

SimulationImage copyrightS.OSSOKINE/A.BUONANNO (MPI GRAVITATIONAL PHYSICS)
Image captionA computer simulation of gravitational waves radiating from two merging black holes

The Astronomer Royal, Sir Martin Rees, said the three leaders honoured by the Nobel Committee were “outstanding individuals whose contributions were distinctive and complementary”.

But he added: “Of course, Ligo’s success was owed to literally hundreds of dedicated scientists and engineers. The fact that the Nobel committee refuses to make group awards is causing them increasingly frequent problems – and giving a misleading and unfair impression of how a lot of science is actually done.”

Many commentators had gravitational waves down as a dead cert to win last year, but the Nobel committee has always been fiercely independent in its choices and has made everyone wait 12 months.

Had the prize been awarded last year, it is very likely that the Scottish physicist Ron Drever would have shared it with Weiss and Thorne.

The trio won all the big science prizes – apart from the Nobel – in the immediate aftermath of the first detection in 2015.

But Drever died in March this year and Nobels are generally not awarded posthumously.

The Scotsman developed some of the early laser systems at Glasgow University before taking this knowledge to Caltech in California, which manages the Washington State Ligo facility.

Glasgow remains the UK hub for the big British contribution to Ligo. Its Institute for Gravitational Research designed and built the suspension system that holds the ultra-still mirrors used in the US and Italian labs.

Catherine O’Riordan, interim co-chief executive of the American Institute of Physics (AIP), said: “Weiss, Barish and Thorne led us to the first detection of gravitational waves and laid the foundation for the new and exciting era we officially entered on September 14, 2015 – the era of gravity wave astronomy.”

This is actually the second Nobel prize to involve gravitational waves. In 1993, Americans Russell Alan Hulse and Joseph Hooton Taylor were awarded the physics prize for work that provided indirect evidence for the warping of space.

line break

Previous winners of the Nobel Prize in physics

2016 – David Thouless, Duncan Haldane and Michael Kosterlitz shared the award for their work on rare phases of matter.

2015 – Takaaki Kajita and Arthur McDonald were awarded the prize the discovery that neutrinos switch between different “flavours”.

2014 – Isamu Akasaki, Hiroshi Amano and Shuji Nakamura won the physics Nobel for developing the first blue light-emitting diodes (LEDs).

2013 – Francois Englert and Peter Higgs shared the spoils for formulating the theory of the Higgs boson particle.

2012 – Serge Haroche and David J Wineland were awarded the prize for their work with light and matter.

2011 – The discovery that the expansion of the Universe was acceleratingearned Saul Perlmutter, Brian P Schmidt and Adam Riess the physics prize.

2010 – Andre Geim and Konstantin Novoselov were awarded the prize for their discovery of the “wonder material” graphene.

line break

Follow Paul and Jonathan on Twitter.